Self-managing a block of flats is a practical option when the people responsible have enough time, relevant knowledge and dependable arrangements for sharing the work. Hiring a professional block management company adds a management fee, but can ease the demands of organising repairs, handling finances and keeping residents informed.
The useful question is whether your current arrangement gives the building the attention it needs without placing an unsustainable burden on a few individuals. This guide explores that decision for resident-owned leasehold buildings in England.
Self-Management vs a Managing Agent: Which Approach Suits Your Building?
The main difference is who carries out the everyday work. With self-management, authorised owners or directors organise it themselves. With a managing agent, a paid team undertakes the responsibilities specified in its appointment.
A Direct Comparison of Self-Management and Professional Support
|
What matters? |
Managing the building yourselves |
Appointing a professional company |
|---|---|---|
|
Time commitment |
Residents make room for administration and follow-up |
Much of the routine work moves to the agent |
|
Spending |
No managing-agent fee, but professional and building costs remain |
Fees reflect the agreed service, with possible extras |
|
Communication |
Owners establish their own system for enquiries |
A defined contact and reporting process can be agreed |
|
Repair organisation |
Residents arrange advice, quotations and access |
The agent coordinates authorised work |
|
Financial oversight |
The board organises collection and reporting |
The agent supplies the agreed financial support |
|
Continuity |
Cover must be arranged when volunteers are unavailable |
Staffing and absence cover should form part of the service |
|
Control |
Decisions follow the building's ownership and governance arrangements |
Reserved decisions remain with the appropriate decision-makers |
What Does Self-Managing a Block of Flats Actually Involve?
Self-management means organising the building's administration, money and upkeep yourselves, while bringing in qualified professionals when their expertise is needed. Somebody must take responsibility for each task and follow it through.
Residents need a clear way to report problems, and directors need a shared record of decisions. Store contracts, invoices and essential contacts somewhere the authorised people can access. Management should not depend entirely on one person's private email account.
Agree cover for holidays and changes of director. If the usual organiser moves away, another person should be able to find the insurance documents, check outstanding repairs and contact the right contractors without starting again.
How Do You Organise Block Maintenance and Contractors?
Good maintenance management deals with immediate problems while preparing for predictable work. Whether residents or an agent coordinate it, the process needs clear priorities, approvals and follow-up.
Deciding Which Repairs Need Urgent Attention
An active leak needs a different response from worn hallway paint. Establish who receives urgent reports and how necessary action is authorised. Bring in suitable specialists where the cause or seriousness is uncertain; a managing agent coordinates that expertise rather than replacing it.
Comparing Quotations and Checking Completed Work
Give contractors a clear description of the job so their prices can be compared fairly. Check what each quotation covers, including access, materials and making good afterwards.
Arrange access with affected residents, record approval and check the result before closing the task. Keep track of unfinished work and recurring defects instead of treating payment of the invoice as proof that the problem has been solved.
Planning Ahead for Larger Maintenance Jobs
Keep a schedule of foreseeable work, such as external decoration, gutter maintenance or renewal of shared equipment. Review it against the property's condition and available funds. This gives residents time to consider costs and allows relevant consultation to be planned before contractors are booked.
What Responsibilities Remain With Resident Directors?
A resident management company (RMC) and a right to manage (RTM) company are different arrangements, but both can involve residents acting as company directors.
Directors still need to supervise the building's management after an agent is appointed. Delegation changes how work is carried out; it does not remove the board's own duties.
Understanding the Leases and Ownership Arrangements
Start with the documents governing your property. The lease provisions help determine which services can be charged for, how contributions are divided and where repair obligations sit.
A share of freehold does not cancel those provisions. Nor does a majority preference automatically establish that a proposed charge is recoverable. Where the wording is uncertain or residents disagree about its meaning, obtain suitable professional advice before proceeding.
Keeping the Management Company Properly Administered
If your building operates through a limited company, its corporate administration needs a separate place on the calendar. Relevant records, annual accounts and confirmation statements cannot be overlooked because the building itself appears to be running smoothly.
Ask who is handling these obligations. An agent's building-management appointment does not necessarily include company secretarial work or preparation of the company's accounts.
How Do You Manage Service Charges and Building Finances?
The people managing the building need to know what residents have paid, which bills are outstanding and how much money remains for future work. A bank statement alone does not show the full picture.
Preparing a Realistic Service Charge Budget
Allow for regular costs and foreseeable maintenance. Simply repeating last year's budget could leave a shortfall if external decoration or another substantial job is approaching.
Check the lease before deciding what to charge and how to divide the cost between flats. Demands must meet the relevant legal requirements, and variable service charges are also subject to rules about reasonableness.
Understanding How Much Money Is Available to Spend
If the building's account contains £10,000 but £8,000 is needed for bills already agreed, only £2,000 remains before allowing for other costs or money reserved for specific work.
Keep a record of unpaid bills alongside payments expected from residents. Unpaid service charges, often called arrears, matter because the building cannot use money that has not arrived. Whoever manages the finances should monitor overdue payments and follow the appropriate process for pursuing them.
Keeping Residents' Contributions Separate From Personal Money
Service charge contributions are generally held on trust. This means the money is held for the leaseholders and must be used for the purposes allowed by the leases; it is not personal spending money for directors or the managing agent.
Use suitable banking arrangements and retain records showing what was collected, what was paid and why.
Setting Money Aside for Future Building Repairs
A reserve fund is money collected in advance towards future costs, such as replacing a shared roof. Check that the leases permit the contributions before collecting them.
Planning these payments can make larger expenses easier to prepare for. However, having a reserve does not guarantee that every repair will be covered, so its balance should be reviewed against the work expected.
How Are Safety Duties and Section 20 Consultation Handled?
The management arrangement does not determine whether relevant statutory requirements apply. Self-managed buildings still need to identify their obligations and arrange competent help where necessary.
Keeping Fire Safety Work Under Review
Depending on the premises and who controls them, duties can include arranging a suitable fire risk assessment, addressing identified risks, maintaining necessary precautions and providing information to residents.
Do not assume that having only a few flats removes these requirements. The assessment and guidance used must suit the property: an older converted house may need a different approach from a recently constructed block.
Keep a record of actions outstanding as well as assessments completed. A report sitting in a folder is of limited practical value if its recommendations have not been considered.
Recognising When Major Works Require Consultation
For qualifying works, the usual Section 20 consultation threshold is a contribution exceeding £250, including VAT, for any individual leaseholder. A qualifying agreement running beyond 12 months may also trigger consultation if any leaseholder pays more than £100 annually towards it.
Example: External Repairs Shared Between Three Flats
Imagine qualifying external repairs costing £6,000, with the leases requiring equal contributions. Each flat's £2,000 share exceeds the works threshold. The small number of owners does not, by itself, remove the consultation requirement.
An informal agreement to proceed is not automatically a substitute for the prescribed process. Incorrect consultation can limit the amount recoverable, unless the tribunal grants dispensation. Establish the procedure early enough to allow for it when planning the project.
Is Self-Management Cheaper Than Paying a Managing Agent?
It can be cheaper in direct management fees, but the fairest comparison includes the remaining costs and the time residents contribute.
Allowing for the Work Behind the Savings
Self-management does not make repairs, insurance or specialist advice free. It also requires residents to invest time in tasks that are easy to underestimate, such as comparing proposals, chasing responses and explaining expenditure.
Understanding the Trade-Offs of Professional Management
An agent introduces another relationship to manage. Directors still need to give clear instructions, consider recommendations and assess whether the service is meeting expectations.
Discuss communication frequency, absence cover and approval limits before appointment. Written arrangements help avoid discovering later that a task everyone assumed was included has no owner.
Should a Victorian Conversion Be Self-Managed?
A Victorian conversion may be suitable for self-management, provided the owners can handle its particular demands. Property age, alterations and the way shared elements serve the flats can matter more than unit numbers alone.
When a Small Building Produces a Large Repair Bill
In a converted house, roof repairs or drainage investigations may involve several households but relatively few contributors. Differences in outlook can then become difficult: one owner may prioritise a lasting repair while another wants to minimise immediate expenditure.
Clear documentation and early discussion help. Check responsibilities before assuming that the flat nearest a defect must pay for it, and explain the options before seeking approval.
Matching Maintenance to the Building's Construction
Previous extensions, changes to internal layouts and earlier repair methods can affect the next maintenance decision. Where applicable, conservation requirements also need to be checked before relevant alterations.
W12's management support for Victorian conversions can help residents bring these practical considerations together with the administration of a shared building.
When Should You Appoint a Managing Agent?
Consider professional help when the workload, complexity or lack of continuity starts preventing reliable management.
Common reasons to review your arrangements include:
- The director who normally organises everything is stepping down.
- Several repairs remain open without a clear next action.
- Residents cannot obtain understandable financial information.
- Significant work is approaching and nobody can coordinate it.
- Management discussions repeatedly turn into personal disagreements.
- Important records are scattered or difficult to retrieve.
Self-management can remain suitable when duties are understood, work is shared and cover is available. Reassess it when the building's needs or residents' circumstances change.
What Should You Ask Before Choosing a Block Management Company?
Ask questions that reveal how the company would work with your board, rather than relying on general assurances of good service.
- Who will be our everyday contact, and how is absence covered?
- What will our regular reports contain?
- Which tasks and visits are included in the fee?
- How are contractors selected and their work checked?
- What spending can you authorise without board approval?
- How are our building's funds held and reported?
- What relevant insurance and redress arrangements do you have?
- What are the notice terms and handover arrangements?
Verify relevant memberships and obtain a written service agreement before making your decision.
FAQs About Managing a Resident-Owned Block
Can We Self-Manage After Acquiring the Right to Manage?
An RTM company can arrange its own day-to-day management or employ an agent. Acquiring the Right to Manage establishes management responsibilities; it does not require every administrative task to be performed personally by the directors.
Can We Keep Some Tasks and Delegate Others?
A tailored appointment may be possible. Decide precisely which duties remain with residents and which move to the provider, including who follows up overdue actions. Gaps between the two arrangements can undermine otherwise useful support.
What Is the First Step When Moving Away From Self-Management?
Agree who has authority to appoint the provider and what help is needed. Prepare the building's documents, financial position and unresolved issues so a proposed service can address the real workload from the outset.
Find the Right Level of Block Management Support With W12
Whether you want to keep an active role or hand over more of the administration, W12 can discuss an arrangement suited to your building and the people responsible for it.
W12 works with buildings in West London and South West London, as well as selected Surrey locations. Explore our block and freehold management services, then tell us which responsibilities you want to retain and where additional help would make a difference.
